Extracellular Ca(2+) ions cause a rapid block of voltage-gated sodium channels, manifest as an apparent reduction of the amplitude of single-channel currents. We examined the influence of residue Tyr-401 in the isoform rNa(V)1.4 on both single-channel conductance and Ca(2+) block. An aromatic residue at this position in the outer mouth of the pore plays a critical role in high-affinity block by the guanidinium toxin tetrodotoxin, primarily due to an electrostatic attraction between the cationic blocker and the system of pi electrons on the aromatic face. We tested whether a similar attraction between small metal cations (Na(+) and Ca(2+)) and this residue would enhance single-channel conductance or pore block, using a series of fluorinated derivatives of phenylalanine at this position. Our results show a monotonic decrease in Ca(2+) block as the aromatic ring is increasingly fluorinated, a result in accord with a cation-pi interaction between Ca(2+) and the aromatic ring. This occurred without a change of single-channel conductance, consistent with a greater electrostatic effect of the pi system on divalent than on monovalent cations. High-level quantum mechanical calculations show that Ca(2+) ions likely do not bind directly to the aromatic ring because of the substantial energetic penalty of dehydrating a Ca(2+) ion. However, the complex of a Ca(2+) ion with its inner hydration shell, Ca(2+)(H(2)O)(6), interacts electrostatically with the aromatic ring in a way that affects the local concentration of Ca(2+) ions in the extracellular vestibule.