More than 80 years of silver mining in the Cobalt area (Ontario, Canada) has led to widespread contamination of water with arsenic. The objective of this study was to determine the impact of changes in redox conditions on the stability of As in samples collected from a tailings wetland in the historic mining camp. Dissolved metal concentrations were monitored while tailings samples (approximately 1300 mg of As kg(-1), pH 7.4) were subjected to 30 days of reduction. Reoxidation of the samples was accomplished by air drying. The As oxidation states in the original, reduced, and reoxidized samples were determined using X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS). Arsenic speciation was affected by changes in redox conditions, resulting in rapid mobilization of As during reduction. Glucose input had a significant impact on the dissolution and speciation of As, suggesting that the As transformation was microbially mediated. When carbon was not limiting, the combination of reducing conditions and lower pH favored the formation of As(-I) species.