Background: The histological features that characterize infective endocarditis in bioprosthetic valves are not accurately defined. Moreover, bioprosthetic valves may have a noninfective, degenerative evolution associated with calcifications, vegetation-like lesions, and inflammatory infiltrates. Such histological findings may be misdiagnosed as infective endocarditis.
Methods: Pathologic analysis of inflamed bioprosthetic valve tissues was conducted retrospectively for 21 patients who underwent surgical removal of a bioprosthetic valve because of suspected infective endocarditis and for 67 patients who underwent surgical removal of a bioprosthetic valve because of noninfective dysfunction. To better define the histological criteria for infective endocarditis, we used quantitative image analysis to compare these 2 groups of patients with respect to vegetations, calcifications, and patterns of inflammation.
Results: Histologically, infective endocarditis in patients with bioprostheses was characterized by demonstration of microorganisms, vegetations, and neutrophil-rich, inflammatory infiltrates. Valve tissue specimens from patients whose bioprosthetic valves were removed because of noninfective complications showed, in 30% of cases, inflammatory infiltrates mainly composed of macrophages and lymphocytes. Inflammatory adherent thrombi that can occur to the surface of noninfective degenerative bioprostheses are differentiated because their vegetations have macrophage-rich content. A neutrophil surface area with a cutoff value of > or =1.5% of the total valve tissue surface area is highly specific (94%) for infective endocarditis.
Conclusions: When no microorganisms are detected and vegetations are not found in bioprosthetic valve tissues during the histological examination, a neutrophil-rich inflammation might better define the term "active endocarditis" in the Duke criteria and would allow differentiation between infective endocarditis and inflammatory, noninfective valve processes in patients with bioprosthetic valves.