Objectives: Although complications (infection, development of granulation tissue) of silicone Montgomery T-tubes have been reported, the microbiological consequences and the origin of granulation tissue have not yet been evaluated.
Study design: A prospective trial.
Methods: Twenty-three Montgomery T-tubes from 10 patients were analyzed with regard to the development of granulation tissue, bacterial growth (including genotyping with polymerase chain reaction), and results of sensitivity testing. Furthermore, stent sterilization (n = 6) was investigated.
Results: Granulation tissue occurred with 74% of the stents, and all specimens showed signs of infection but no foreign body reaction. The predominant organisms were Staphylococcus aureus (35%) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (17%). The differences between groups with and without granulation tissue were significant for P aeruginosa. Polymerase chain reaction fingerprinting of the S aureus obtained from 15 stents (n = 3 patients) revealed a total of seven different genotypes. Whereas two of these patients harbored six different genotypes of S aureus, the third patient was persistently colonized by S aureus over a 15-month period with the identical genotype. Susceptibility testing showed most commonly (65%) sensitivity to a combination of amoxicillin-clavulanate and ofloxacin. After sterilization, 92% of analyzed stent segments showed no bacterial growth.
Conclusions: Granulation tissue commonly occurred next to the silicone (subglottic area, stoma) where S aureus and P aeruginosa were commonly isolated. A combination of mechanical irritation and bacterial infection seems to account for the development of granulation tissue. Polymerase chain reaction fingerprinting showed both prolonged persistence and a change of colonizing strains after multiple stent replacements. A combination of amoxicillin-clavulanate and ofloxacin is the most effective antibiotic therapy. Sterilization of the cost-intensive silicone stents is feasible, and reuse in the same patient is justifiable from economic aspects.