Changes in lipid composition have recently been shown to exert appreciable influences on the activities of membrane-bound proteins and peptides. We tested the hypothesis that the conformational states of rhodopsin linked to visual signal transduction are related to biophysical properties of the membrane lipid bilayer. For bovine rhodopsin, the meta I-meta II conformational transition was studied in egg phosphatidylcholine (PC) recombinants versus the native rod outer segment (ROS) membranes by means of flash photolysis. Formation of metarhodopsin II was observed by the change in absorbance at 478 nm after a single actinic flash was delivered to the sample. The meta I/meta II ratio was investigated as a function of both temperature and pH. The data clearly demonstrated thermodynamic reversibility of the transition for both the egg PC recombinants and the native ROS membranes. A significant shift of the apparent pK(a) for the acid-base equilibrium to lower values was evident in the egg PC recombinant, with little meta II produced under physiological conditions. Calculations of the membrane surface pH using a Poisson-Boltzmann model suggested the free energies of the meta I and meta II states were significantly affected by electrostatic properties of the bilayer lipids. In the ROS membranes, phosphatidylserine (PS) is needed for full formation of meta II, in combination with phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) and polyunsaturated docosahexaenoic acid (DHA; 22:6omega3) chains. We propose that the PS surface potential leads to an accumulation of hydronium ions, H(3)O(+), in the electrical double layer, which drive the reaction together with the large negative spontaneous curvature (H(0)) conferred by PE plus DHA chains. The elastic stress/strain of the bilayer arises from an interplay of the approximately zero H(0) from PS and the negative H(0) due to the PE headgroups and polyunsaturated chains. The lipid influences are further explained in terms of matching of the bilayer spontaneous curvature to the curvature at the lipid/rhodopsin interface, as formulated by the Helfrich bending energy. These new findings guide current ideas as to how bilayer properties govern the conformational energetics of integral membrane proteins. Moreover, they yield knowledge of how membrane lipid-protein interactions involving acidic phospholipids such as PS and neutral polyunsaturated DHA chains are implicated in key biological functions such as vision.